free web hosting | free hosting | Business Hosting | Free Website Submission | shopping cart | php hosting

SITE HOME | REVIEWS INDEX | COMICS | NOVELS | MAGAZINES | MISCELLANEOUS | MAIL

SPIKE & DRU: THE QUEEN OF HEARTS

Review 1 - Richard Morgan          Review 2 - Marc

PLOT

On their way to Sunnydale, Spike and Dru decide to take a short break at the town of St. Louis, taking in the sites and local policemen, as they make their way there.

Unbeknown to them though, they're not the only demons in town, as it appears the local Casino boss also has some involvement with the dark side, as whenever someone has a winning streak they are taken to his room and never seen again.  But what will happen now that Spike & Dru attend the casino, and Dru gets a winning streak?  To find out you'll have to read this comic full of action, romance...blood and strip clubs!

ART

WOW!  While the similarities between Sook and Mike Mignola's art will no doubt be obvious to comic fans, it still manages to impress.  While not exactly suitable for those under the age of 16, the art is truly breathtaking, and probably the darkest yet for the Buffy comic.  In one issue we get a strip club, topless Dru and blood on every page.  The colours are also well thought out, and Guy Major even leaves out the trademark green vamps for one issue.

WRITING

A truly superb story, with all the elements which make it one of the best comics yet, but sadly a few errors in the text (which may or may not be the fault of Golden) really spoil the story.  In the day of spell checks and editors you think these little things would be caught before the comic went into production.  Other than that Golden's tone really allows Sook's art to florish, and this time Dru gets the most comic time, rather than the last one-shot when it was Spike who got all the attention.

OVERALL

For all those people who didn't buy this, then shame on you.  Queen of Hearts is visually the best Buffy comic book out there, and the story is good too.  While there may be no James Marsters attached to this project, everything else that made Paint the Town Red a success is here, so go down to your local comic shop and demand it now!

 

SPIKE AND DRU
THE QUEEN OF HEARTS

Writer: CHRISTOPHER GOLDEN

Artist: RYAN SOOK

Letterer: PAT BROSSEAU

Colours: GUY MAJORS


Reviewer: RICHARD MORGAN

WRITING RATING: 10/10

ART RATING: 8/10

OVERALL RATING: 8/10


 

WHAT HAS HAPPENED BEFORE?

Well, nothing we know about.  This is Spike and Dru a few days before they enter Sunnydale, so this one-shot takes place before the first one-shot, Paint the Town Red.

This issue features Ryan Sook's third Buffy story - the first being PTTR, the second, Bad Dog from the Annual and finally this issue.  All of the team from PTTR have returned apart from James Marsters, Spike himself, who has commitments on the show.  It's a shame they couldn't get him to do this issue as well.

WRITING

I couldn't help but think that this issue would suck writing-wise.  I thought that after Golden's less than impressive story in the Annual, and the whole Angel limited series (it's best if we try to forget about that isn't it?) that this issue was to be the same.  How wrong was I?  Extremely wrong.   I could not be more wrong.  It's like me saying, "The Annointed One is a sorely missed character" - I was that wrong!

The comic begins with Spike driving his car with Dru by his side.  In the first three pages we get an explosion of great writing, great artwork and a killing (by our heroes, no less).  Spike's singing reminded me of the scene in Lover's Walk when Spike leaves Sunnydale blasting out a rendition of My Way.

Golden's back on top form, as he was with issue 12 of the ongoing.  He makes Dru mad and Spike cool.  Examples...

Dru: I think I hear a whistling in my veins.   Now it's a happy tune.

Spike: They call me Spike, actually, long story, kinda bloody too.

Golden brings the action to St. Louis.  The story revolves around a casino on a boat called, appropriately enough, The Queen of Hearts.  Here Golden introduces a villain called Due Zachariah King, a mean old sonofabitch.  Cool and debonair on the outside, but as this is a Buffy story, he's not all that he seems.  The villains in this issue are some kind of weird mutated fish demons.  Not like the ones in Go Fish or in the opening of The Wish, but big bulky green scaled smelly demons with ripped shirts, which somehow reminded me of The Incredible Hulk.  They give Spike and Dru a run for their money.  Zachariah is the 'boss' of the mutated fish demon things (he is also one himself, just a lot bigger and with more arms) but I could see this coming - it wasn't hard to spot.

The finale is fantastic.  A battle between not only between Spike and Dru against the mutated fish demons, but these huge jellyfish creatures called The Spawn of Ickthala are after the mutated fish demons as well.   (This is because as one of the demons fell into the water, the Ickthalas got the taste for them and went after more.)

This issue is definitely a lot bloodier and has content that I would not recommend for younger readers.  One thing that shocked me was that sex has been introduced into the Buffy line.  Spike and Dru lay naked on a bed, which suggests that they had some kind of 'action' the night/day before.  I wouldn't have thought that they would show it.  I guess it was important as it showed a symbolism of their love, but I felt it was a bit too much.  Although bravo to Golden for introducing the matter into the line.

Dru gets a lot more 'screen' time in this issue.   With PTTR, Dru didn't have a lot to do, but here it's the loveable mad Dru we first fell in love with.  What let down PTTR a fraction was the fact that Dru was not featured heavily.  Sure she was there but Spike seemed to take centre stage.   But with this tale they both get their fair share.  Which is how it should be.

Verdict: after this last few attempts (Annual, Angel limited series) Golden is back on track with this issue.  Hats off to the man who should write for the show!

ART

Sook returns to the characters he does best.  Sook is my favourite Buffy artist, so perhaps I might be biased when reviewing.  But when I say that Sook is a great artist, it's no lie.  A style that is very unlike what I've seen before.  I think that Sook's leaning further away from his Mike Mignola comparisons (saying that, on the bottom of page 26, with the close-up of the green demon, it is very Mignola.  Quite uncanny).

Sook does a great job with the characters, he makes Dru very sexy in the shot of her pole dancing.  He makes Spike look extremely cool and calm in the end fight scene.  He does a fabulous job with everyone else.   Since PTTR, I feel that he has been putting in more detail into his work - more fine lines, more shadows, more facial expressions.  Very nice too.

After seeing Sook's magnificent pencils in this issue, it's hard to picture any other artist doing Spike and Dru, I doubt they could have the same effect as Sook does.  The only complaint I have of Sook in this issue is on page 11, the bottom of the page with the picture of Spike saying "Bloody hell".   It doesn't look right.  It's been overdone on the lining effects.  But we won't condemn him for it as it's not a usual pattern (take note Mr Gomez).  Sook seems to be doing a great job drawing figures.  Not the numbers but the body shapes.   He seems to get the arms in the right places.  Take the Dru pole dancing shot.   The arms are in the right place, shoulders where they should be, legs are drawn magnificently.  I like this guy a lot.  If I were a woman, I'd marry him.

Verdict: Repeat after me.   RYAN...SOOK...IS...GOD!

NITPICKS

Lettering.  It's great - when Brosseau doesn't leave out letters, but I noticed many mistakes - 'uicy' when it should be 'juicy', 'o' when it should be 'to'.  A slight cock-up over at Dark Horse.  It's off-putting but an easy mistake to make.

I like Major's colours.  It's funny how with Richards' and Zanier's work he piles on the blues but with Sook he uses a lot more different tones of dark purple.  Seems odd.  Cover wasn't all that, too blue for my liking.

OVERALL

Go and buy it now!  Stop reading this review and go and buy it!  GO NOW!

Next up: Spike and Dru in Buffy #14.  It'll be interesting to see how Richards draws the characters.  Also in the pages of QoH, there's an advert for the Angel ongoing series.  I'm not saying much on this apart from "I hope the interiors are better than the crap advert that's supposed to be selling it!"

Back to the top

SPIKE AND DRU
THE QUEEN OF HEARTS


Reviewer: MARC

WRITING RATING: 5/5

ART RATING: 5/5

OVERALL RATING: 5/5